Can eir requests be refused on cost grounds

Author: dirf

August undefined, 2024

WebIf your request for information is refused on cost grounds, we will offer advice and discuss with you how you can possibly make a new modified request that can be met within the cost limit. For requests that are less than the £450, we may still charge the full costs of photocopying, printing and postage where it exceeds £50. If we intend to ... Webyour request falls under the exception under regulation 12(4)(b) as ‘manifestly unreasonable’. Under the EIR public authorities may refuse requests that are manifestly (i.e. obviously or clearly) unreasonable when the cost of compliance is too great. Our searches have revealed that the authority holds a significant number of

Percentage of freedom of information requests refused …

WebMar 10, 2013 · Recent case law suggests that where requests can’t be refused on cost grounds (section 12 – for example if it would take a long time to read through and redact material), section 14 may be used. However, it is still unclear where the line can be drawn – the information in these cases ran to thousands of pages. ... EIR requests ... Webauthority can withhold information. A request for information can be refused if: • The information is not held • The request is manifestly unreasonable • The request is too … candiru worm

When can we refuse a request for environmental …

Webrefused on cost grounds under the FOI Act were it not environmental information, could potentially be refused as 'manifestly unreasonable' under regulation 12(4)(b) of the EIR. … WebJul 11, 2011 · There is no direct s.12 equivalent allowing refusal on grounds of cost, but often authorities will argue that the exception (the EIR term for an exemption) for requests which are ‘manifestly unreasonable’, can be used to refuse requests which will be expensive to comply with. DEFRA’s guidance and case law appear to support this. WebA All EIR requests must be responded to in writing within 20 working days, unless there are ... will charge any disbursement costs for communicating the information which are over and ... Q What do I do if my Environmental request is refused? A If your request is refused you can appeal against this decision by asking for an internal review ... fish processing in yakutat ak

Percentage of freedom of information requests refused …

The Exemption Index: Section 12 – refusing on grounds of cost

Webeir and open eir are trading names of eircom Limited, Registered as a Branch in Ireland Number 907674, Incorporated in Jersey Number 116389. ... but it can give you a more … WebRegulation 12 (4) (a) When you don’t hold the information that has been requested, you need to tell the applicant. Under the Regulations this counts as a refusal of the request. … candiru dick fishWebThere are lots of reasons why an authority may lawfully refuse to disclose information. FOI law allows an authority to refuse to comply with a request if, for example: it does not hold the information; it would cost too much to comply with the request; the request is vexatious or repeated; or; the information is exempt from disclosure. fish processing plant aberdeen

"WebJul 27, 2024 · Percentage of freedom of information requests refused on cost grounds: FOI review. Published 27 July 2024. Directorate. Constitution and Cabinet Directorate. … " - Can eir requests be refused on cost grounds

Can eir requests be refused on cost grounds

Using Freedom of Information legislation

WebCan EIR requests be refused on cost grounds? There may, however, be material differences between a request that can be refused under section 12 of FOIA (the costs … WebThere is no charge for submitting an FOI/EIR request. However, in some cases, we may have to charge a fee to cover the costs of providing the information. For example, where ... We reserve the right to refuse a request where the estimated cost of processing exceeds £450. However, before refusing a request on this basis, we will always work ...

Did you know?

WebA simple request can be processed faster by the agency than one that is complex. Simple requests are typically more targeted and seek fewer pages of records. ... -mail to the designated appeal authority of the agency stating that you are appealing the initial decision made on your request. There is no fee or cost involved. After an independent ... WebAlternatively, you can call us on 1800 303 733 to reschedule your appointment. Customer Care. Continuity of customer care is of vital importance to us during this difficult time. We …

WebRefund Request. The below form will allow a customer to request a refund in an easy & timely manner. Please note that we will make every attempt to close this refund by … WebThese Regulations cover the fee that can be charged where the cost of responding exceeds £600. The Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 (Time for Compliance) Regulations 2016 ... The EIRs permit Scottish public authorities to refuse a request if an exception under regulation 10(4) or 10(5) applies and the public interest in making the ...

WebLocal authorities cannot refuse to answer EIR requests on cost grounds, but they can charge you for the time taken. Repeat and vexatious requests An authority can refuse … WebCan EIR requests be refused on cost grounds? There may, however, be material differences between a request that can be refused under section 12 of FOIA (the costs limit) and a request that can be refused as manifestly unreasonable under the EIR on the grounds of costs or diversion of resources. This exception is subject to a public interest …

WebJul 17, 2024 · There are six lawful bases for processing in GDPR Article 6, but only consent or legitimate interests are relevant to disclosure under the FOI or EIR. It may be possible to ask staff for their consent to disclose their names. However, given the particularly high threshold for consent to be valid (see GDPR Article 7 ) and the imbalance of power ...

WebRequests under the EIR can also be made verbally, e.g. over the phone. You should include the following with both types of request: Your name and address (physical or electronic) for correspondence; ... If your request is refused on cost grounds, we will try to advise you where possible how best to make a fresh narrower request that can be met ... can disability be curedWebSometimes we may need to refuse to provide the information you have requested through a Freedom of Information request. Both the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA) and the Environmental Information Regulations 2004 (EIR) allow us to withhold certain information if there is a valid reason for us to do so. This might be because the information: can disabled people go to collegeWebMay 29, 2024 · Can EIR requests be refused on cost grounds? There may, however, be material differences between a request that can be refused under section 12 of FOIA … c and isWebSubmit an FOI request (This form can also be used for EIR requests) Refused Requests. There are certain occasions where a request for information may be refused. These are: The request is not valid (see above for valid request criteria), The cost of compliance will exceed the appropriate limit (FOI only), The request is repeated or vexatious, can disability insurance be deducted on taxesWebThe independent public official responsible for promoting and enforcing Scotland's freedom of information (FOI) law. FOI gives everyone the right to access information held by Scottish public authorities. can disability tax credit be transferredWebRequests with costs in excess of 'appropriate limit' refused. No - requests cannot be refused on grounds of cost alone. At our discretion. Charges. Yes - can make a … fish processing plantWebthat is manifestly unreasonable on vexatious grounds under the EIR. 12. There may, however, be material differences between a request that can be refused under section … can disability pay for college